The Commission on Human Rights (CHR) said authorities must respect protesters’ rights even when maintaining public order, following reports of alleged abuses during demonstrations held alongside the ASEAN Summit.

According to the CHR, 11 individuals, including one minor, were reportedly apprehended in Manila, while more than 200 people, including several minors, were brought to Camp Bagong Diwa following protests in Muntinlupa City on November 15.

“While law enforcement authorities have a duty to maintain public order, they must exercise maximum tolerance and restraint, ensuring that any intervention complies with the principles of legality, necessity, and proportionality,” the Commission said in its November 18 statement.

It stressed that the constitutional rights to freedom of expression and peaceful assembly must be respected regardless of the views expressed or policies challenged.

During on-site monitoring, CHR personnel observed individuals with visible injuries and noted concerns about congestion and ventilation in the temporary holding area, according to the Commission.

It was also verifying reports of mistreatment and restrictions on food deliveries intended for those apprehended.

The CHR said people in police custody must be treated humanely, provided with adequate food, water, and medical care, and afforded their constitutional and due process rights, including access to competent and independent legal counsel.

The Commission also reminded authorities to observe legally prescribed detention periods regardless of the number apprehended.

The CHR expressed serious concern that its lawyers and investigators were initially denied access to Camp Bagong Diwa on November 15 and were allowed entry only late that evening, after several hours of delay, underscoring that authorities must respect its constitutional investigative and visitorial powers.

“Timely and unhindered access is essential to independently monitor the conditions and treatment of persons under police custody and ensure the protection of their human rights,” it said.

The CHR said it was coordinating with authorities to verify the circumstances and legal grounds for the arrests, the status of those apprehended, and their conditions in custody, including those of minors.

The Commission said it would seek police and medical records and gather accounts from concerned individuals to inform its determination of whether human rights violations occurred and any recommendations for legal, administrative, or policy measures.

Follow Tan Briones & Associates on LinkedIn for more legal updates and law-related articles.